I don't have a problem with guys that under performed in a league, as long as it's not part of a trend.
For instance, Pelletier has always managed to step up to the league he played in.
You don't want a guy going from one league to a tourney and just doing well there.
Puljujarvi looked like the 2nd coming, until he wasn't.
And he was a top rated player.
Tye Raty looked like a start in EDM, during camp and pre-season.
How many of those do you really want to sign.
If we are not going to sign Rodriguez, then he's prime for a PTO offer.
Same with Milano.
I know that goes against taking shots at potential boom/busts, but it is what it is.
The players are generally scouted a lot, so reasons for not drafting them are not always size or a poor season.